← News
Tax

Supreme Court: State surcharge on sales tax upheld as valid

The Supreme Court held that a surcharge on sales tax is a permissible enhancement of the tax rate, not a prohibited tax on tax, and upheld the State’s power to levy it.

The Supreme Court, delivering its judgment on 4 November 2026 (2026 INSC 1192), ruled that the surcharge imposed under the Orissa Sales Tax Act, 1947 and the Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 is within the legislative competence of the State. The Court concluded that the surcharge is an enhancement of the sales‑tax rate and therefore falls within Entry 54 of List II of the Constitution.

The appellants, Arjun Flour Mills and others, challenged surcharge provisions in the Orissa Sales Tax Act, the Punjab General Sales Tax Act and the Punjab Social Security Act, 2000, contending that the surcharge amounted to a prohibited ‘tax on tax’. They argued that the surcharge could not be passed on to buyers and thus constituted a tax on income rather than on the sale of goods, violating the constitutional limitation on State taxation powers.

The central issue was whether a surcharge, even when the dealer cannot shift it to the consumer, is a tax on the sale of goods within the State’s authority. Relying on the earlier decisions in S. Kodar and Hoechst Pharmaceuticals, the Court observed that the subject of the levy remains the sale of goods and that the measure of tax may be any reasonable formula. The fact that the surcharge is computed as a percentage of the tax payable does not alter its character; it remains a tax on sales, not a tax on income.

Consequently, the Court affirmed the continued validity of the S. Kodar ratio, ordered that the appeals concerning the Orissa and Punjab sales‑tax surcharge provisions be assigned for determination, and directed that the appeals arising under the Punjab Social Security Act be referred to a Division Bench for further consideration.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Arjun Flour Mills vs The State Of Odisha Finance Department ... (2026 INSC 1192).