Supreme Court: Section 197 not applicable to public servant in forgery case
The Supreme Court restored criminal proceedings, holding that the public servant’s alleged forgery was not done in discharge of official duties and Section 197 did not apply.
The Supreme Court, comprising Justices K.V. Viswanathan and Arun Palli, set aside the High Court’s order that had quashed two criminal cases (RCC 1020 of 2023 and RCC 119 of 2024) against a public servant, holding that the proceedings could continue. The appellant, a trustee of a charitable trust, had alleged that the public servant colluded with officials to forge documents and obtain an illegal mutation entry, leading to FIRs and charge‑sheets under the Indian Penal Code.
The central issue was whether the alleged acts fell within the scope of the public servant’s official duties, thereby invoking the sanction requirement of Section 197 of the Criminal Procedure Code, as amended by Maharashtra law to Section 156(3). The Court applied the test that the act must have a reasonable nexus with the servant’s functions. It found that forging documents and manipulating land records were outside the servant’s authorized responsibilities and were not performed in discharge of official duties.
Consequently, the Court held that Section 197 and the deemed‑sanction provision were inapplicable, and the application for sanction had been made to an incompetent authority. The High Court’s quash order was deemed untenable, and the criminal cases were restored for trial. The judgment reaffirmed that public servants cannot claim protection under Section 197 when alleged misconduct is unrelated to their official functions.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Ashok vs Mahesh (2026 INSC 1235).