Supreme Court: Ryotwari Patta on Government Poramboke land declared ultra vires
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals, held the 2011 Ryotwari Patta illegal and ordered demolition, restoration and disciplinary action.
The Supreme Court, comprising Justices S.V.N. Bhatti and N.V. Anjaria, dismissed three civil appeals filed by the flat owners and others, holding that the Ryotwari Patta granted in 2011 over a 0.72‑acre parcel in Tiruvallur district was ultra vires and illegal.
The land, recorded since 1911 as Government Poramboke Kanakkan Kuttai, had been issued a Ryotwari Patta to P. Ramadoss in 2011, mortgaged to Tamil Nadu Mercantile Bank and later subdivided for twenty flats. The Commissioner of Land Administration set aside the patta in 2019, prompting the present litigation.
The Court examined whether the parcel qualified as ryot land under Sections 3(15)‑(16) of the Tamil Nadu Estates (Abolition) Act, 1948 and its 1974 amendment. It found the earliest revenue records identified the area as a tank, a water‑body expressly excluded from the definition of ryot land, and noted that Section 14‑A prohibits issuance of a Ryotwari Patta over Government Poramboke land. The statutory limitation periods for such grants had also expired in the 1970s, rendering the 2011 grant beyond jurisdiction.
Consequently, the Court ordered demolition of the unauthorised structures on 0.22 acre, restoration of the water body, allocation of an alternate site to the flat owners, and directed disciplinary and criminal proceedings against the errant officials, while leaving the bank free to pursue remedies against the mortgagor.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: S. Gururaj vs The Additional Chief Secretary/ ... (2026 INSC 1146).