← News
Civil

Supreme Court: Restores Compensation to Minor Victim of Electrocution

The Supreme Court set aside the High Court order and reinstated the trial court's award of compensation to the minor plaintiff.

The Supreme Court, comprising Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar, allowed the appeal filed by Rekha, a minor, and set aside the High Court's order that had cancelled the trial‑court award of Rs 8,70,000 compensation for electrocution injury.

Rekha alleged that in 2011 she suffered severe burns and permanent disability after contacting an 11 kV transmission line that was hanging low because of the respondents’ negligence. The trial court accepted her testimony and medical evidence and awarded compensation, but the High Court reversed the award on the ground of suspicion and delay in reporting.

The principal issue was whether an appellate court could overturn a trial‑court finding of liability merely on a vague doubt about the incident, without a finding that the plaintiff’s evidence was unreliable. The Supreme Court held that appellate courts must respect trial‑court findings unless there is a material defect in the evidence or a misappreciation of fact.

Emphasising that civil cases are decided on the pre‑ponderance of probability, the Court observed that the trial judge had correctly evaluated the plaintiff’s testimony and supporting documents, and that the respondents had failed to produce positive evidence to rebut the claim. Consequently, the High Court’s order was set aside and the trial‑court judgment and decree were restored.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Rekha vs Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Limited (2026 INSC 1216).