← News
Civil

Supreme Court: Removal of CISF constable quashed for procedural unfairness

The Supreme Court set aside the removal order, reinstating the constable with back wages, finding the departmental inquiry violated natural justice and was disproportionate.

The Supreme Court, by a two‑judge bench, allowed the appeal of a CISF constable who had been removed from service, quashing the removal order and directing his reinstatement with back wages and benefits.

The appellant had applied for extended leave to care for his seriously ill wife and submitted a conditional resignation under stress. He was later charged with three offences, removed from service, and complained of denial of Hindi translations of the charge sheet, denial of a defence assistant, and reliance on earlier minor penalties.

The Court examined whether the departmental inquiry complied with natural‑justice principles and Rule 36 of the CISF Rules, 2001. It found no written direction for the appellant to appear, insufficient proof of his participation in the alleged video circulation, improper reliance on past minor penalties, and denial of timely translations and assistance, thereby violating Rule 36(8)(a) and Article 14.

Finding the penalty of removal manifestly excessive and shocking the conscience, the Court set aside the High Court’s judgment and review order, quashed the removal, and ordered reinstatement without ordering a fresh inquiry.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Sumit Kumar vs Union Of India (2026 INSC 1221).