Supreme Court: Regulation allowing pension deduction from PSC salary upheld
The Supreme Court dismissed challenges and upheld Regulation 7(2) permitting pension deduction from the salary of retired officers serving on the Uttarakhand PSC.
The Supreme Court, in a judgment delivered on 4 November 2026 (2026 INSC 1194), upheld the validity of Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission (PSC) Conditions of Service Regulations, rejecting the contention that the provision allowing deduction of a retired officer’s pension from the salary of a PSC post is unconstitutional.
Retired Lieutenant General M.C. Bhandari and former PCS officer Sohan Lal had been appointed respectively as Chairman and Member of the Uttarakhand PSC, with their remuneration fixed under Regulation 7(1). An Office Memorandum dated 16 September 2008 applied Regulation 7(2), which mandates that the pension of a retired officer be deducted from the salary while he or she holds the post. The petitioners challenged this deduction as violative of Articles 14, 16 and 318 of the Constitution, arguing that it amounted to unequal treatment.
The Court held that Regulation 7(2) was a valid exercise of the power conferred on the Governor under Article 318, describing the deduction as a temporary withholding of pension during the tenure of the appointment rather than a permanent alteration of service conditions. It observed that the provision did not place the appointee at a disadvantage compared with other officers and that the equal‑pay‑for‑equal‑work principle was inapplicable. Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s declaration of unconstitutionality and allowed the appeals.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: State Of Uttarkhand Thr. Chief ... vs M.C.Bhandari (2026 INSC 1194).