Supreme Court: Refund, interest and compensation awarded in delayed apartment delivery case
The Supreme Court ordered a refund of the appellant's outlay with interest, granted compensation and upheld the bank's service deficiency finding.
The Supreme Court, comprising Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasima and Alok Aradhe, dismissed the appeal of K. Madhusudhan Rao and directed the Commission to pay a refund of Rs 1,27,34,726 with 12% simple interest, Rs 15 lakh compensation, and a Rs 2 lakh award for bank service deficiency.
The appellant had paid Rs 51,11,576 to the builder and Rs 76,23,150 to HDFC Bank under a tripartite loan, but possession of the residential apartment was not delivered as agreed, prompting claims for refund, interest, rent compensation and bank liability.
The Court examined the extent of refund, the applicable interest rate, the entitlement to rent compensation and whether the bank had performed its duties. Relying on unjust enrichment provisions of the Contract Act and the 12% interest clause in the Sale Agreement, it limited the refund to the actual amount paid and rejected the rent claim as a double recovery.
The Court affirmed the finding of bank service deficiency, noting the bank had not verified construction progress, and ordered a Rs 2 lakh award. It retained the balance pending the bank’s appeal, allowed the appellant’s name change, and awarded no costs.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: K. Madhusudhan Rao vs M/S Lodha Healthy Constructions And ... (2026 INSC 1131).