← News
Civil

Supreme Court: High Court's Modification of Arbitration Award Set Aside

The Supreme Court restored the original arbitral award, holding the High Court exceeded its Section 37 jurisdiction by altering it on a subjective 'shocking conscience' ground.

The Supreme Court, comprising Justices J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran, allowed the appeal of M/s Marino Dredgeco Ltd. and set aside the High Court’s order that had modified an arbitral award in favour of the contractor. The Court reinstated the award and dismissed the Port Trust’s appeal.

Marino Dredgeco Ltd. had performed dredging work for the Port of Kolkata and later sought payment for additional re‑dredging caused by siltation and erroneous soil data. The arbitral tribunal awarded compensation for the extra work based on measurements, invoices and joint assessments. The High Court altered the award, reasoning that the quantum of additional work, exceeding 70% of the original contract, shocked its conscience.

The Supreme Court examined the scope of Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, which permits limited interference only when an award is patently illegal, perverse, or contrary to public policy. It held that a subjective perception of shock does not satisfy the statutory grounds for modification, especially after the 2015 amendment that restricts court intervention on the merits or size of an award.

Consequently, the Court restored the original arbitral award, allowed Marino Dredgeco Ltd.’s appeal, and dismissed the Port Trust’s appeal, emphasizing that courts cannot alter awards merely because they appear excessive or unsettling to judicial conscience.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: M/S Marino Dredgeco Limited vs The Board Of Trustees Of The Port Of ... (2026 INSC 1238).