← News
Civil

Supreme Court: High Court bail orders set aside for ignoring video evidence

The Supreme Court set aside the Patna High Court’s bail orders for three accused, directing fresh consideration while interim bail continued under existing conditions.

The Supreme Court, comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu, allowed the appeals filed by Nagendra Ray and set aside the Patna High Court’s orders granting anticipatory and regular bail to three accused in the May 2024 shooting that killed Ray’s son. The apex court directed that the bail applications be revived and remitted to the High Court for fresh consideration, while interim bail would continue under the conditions previously imposed.

The appellant, the father of the deceased victim, had challenged the High Court’s decision on the ground that the court had not examined the police‑recorded video footage of the incident nor the Section 161 statements of witnesses who had identified the accused. The central issue before the Supreme Court was whether the High Court had correctly exercised its discretion in granting bail without evaluating this material evidence, which is essential for assessing the likelihood of the accused’s participation in the offence and the risk of tampering with evidence.

The Court held that bail applications require an independent assessment of all relevant material and a recorded reasoning, citing the principle articulated in Assistant Commissioner v. Shukla & Brothers. By omitting the video and witness statements, the High Court failed to fulfil this requirement, rendering its orders invalid. Consequently, the Supreme Court set aside the bail orders, revived the applications and remitted them to the High Court for a fresh hearing, with the interim bail conditions to remain in force until a new decision is rendered.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Nagendra Ray vs The State Of Bihar (2026 INSC 1139).