Supreme Court: Fee hike for self‑financing engineering college cannot be imposed retrospectively
The Supreme Court held that fee revisions announced after admission cannot be applied to students admitted before the notification, ordering refund of excess fees.
The Supreme Court, by a two‑judge bench comprising Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe, partially allowed the appeals filed by Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College against the State of West Bengal, holding that the fee increase notified on 16 October 2023 could not be imposed on students who had secured admission to the 2023‑27 B.Tech programme before that date.
Students admitted to the 2023‑27 B.Tech batch had paid fees based on the fee structure in force at the time of admission. On 16 October 2023 the State issued a notification raising the ceiling for fees payable by self‑financing professional colleges. The students challenged the subsequent demand for higher fees, arguing that the fee ceiling should apply only to admissions made after the notification. The principal issue before the Court was whether a fee fixed at the time of admission could be altered mid‑stream and whether the 2023 notification operated retrospectively.
The Court examined AICTE Regulation 7, the TMA Pai and Inamdar judgments, and the National Education Policy‑2020, concluding that fee structures must be communicated before admission and may be varied only in exceptional circumstances. It held that the wording of the State’s notification did not intend retrospective application, and that allowing mid‑stream revisions would undermine students’ right to certainty. Accordingly, the Division Bench’s equity‑based approach was set aside, the college was directed to refund the excess amount collected, and each party was ordered to bear its own costs.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College vs The State Of West Bengal (2026 INSC 1120).