Supreme Court: Conversion to Islam Does Not Grant Backward Class Muslim Reservation
The Supreme Court ruled that converting to Islam does not make a person a member of a notified Backward Class Muslim community, rendering the 2024 Government Order unconstitutional.
The Supreme Court dismissed the Special Leave Petition filed by Sameer Ahamed N, a Hindu‑born individual who converted to Islam, and upheld the quashing of the 2024 Government Order that granted Backward Class Muslim (Labbai) certificates on the basis of conversion. The judgment was delivered by a two‑judge bench comprising Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar.
Born in 1993 and raised as a Hindu, the petitioner embraced Islam in 2015 and subsequently applied for a community certificate identifying him as a member of the Labbai Backward Class, a Muslim caste notified for reservation benefits. The issuing authority rejected his application, prompting the petitioner to challenge the decision. The High Court affirmed the rejection and struck down the 2024 Government Order that allowed conversion‑based certification, raising the question whether mere religious conversion confers membership in a notified backward class and whether the order complies with constitutional provisions.
The Court held that backward‑class status is determined by birth or lineage, not solely by religious affiliation, and that private religious bodies lack authority to adjudicate statutory reservation rights. It observed that Articles 15(4) and 16(4) of the Constitution require demonstrable social and educational backwardness, which the Government Order failed to substantiate. Consequently, the order was declared unconstitutional, the petition dismissed, and the petitioner’s claim for a Backward Class Muslim certificate rejected.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: The Secretary To Government vs Sameer Ahamed N (2026 INSC 1129).