Supreme Court: Compulsory retirements of government servants upheld
The Supreme Court upheld the validity of compulsory retirements of fourteen government employees, ruling the orders were non‑punitive and consistent with the 2017 circular.
The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals of Chatur Singh Dhruw and others, upholding the compulsory retirement orders issued by the Chhattisgarh government. The bench comprising Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Manmohan affirmed the validity of the 2017 circular that mandated retirement of employees who had reached the age of fifty years or completed twenty years of service. The Court held that the retirements were not arbitrary, discriminatory or punitive and did not infringe any constitutional right.
The petitioners, originally appointed as peons and later promoted to Assistant Grade‑III in the Legal Metrology Department, were retired on 9 October 2017 under the circular’s screening process. Fourteen employees satisfied the age or service‑length criteria, and a committee evaluated them on honesty, integrity, physical capacity, efficiency and overall service record, including grades from recent Annual Confidential Reports. The petitioners argued that reliance on adverse confidential‑report entries that were never communicated to them rendered the retirements arbitrary and punitive.
The Supreme Court concluded that the screening committee had applied the circular’s uniform criteria to all fourteen eligible employees and that the inclusion of recent confidential‑report grades, even if not individually communicated, was permissible in compulsory retirement proceedings. Consequently, the Court dismissed the appeals and upheld the High Court judgments that had affirmed the retirements. The decision clarified that adverse entries in confidential reports may be considered in retirement decisions, provided the process follows the statutory circular and does not amount to punishment.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Chatur Singh Dhruw vs The State Of Chhattisgarh (2026 INSC 1205).