← News
Civil

Supreme Court: Cancellation of e‑tender for sand mining deemed unlawful

The Supreme Court set aside the Board’s cancellation of the September 2025 sand‑mining e‑tender, restoring the tender and directing allotment to the appellants.

The Supreme Court, comprising Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi, allowed the appeals of Sahakar Global Ltd. and M/S Dhanlaxmi Merchandise Pvt. Ltd., holding that the Board’s cancellation of the September 2025 e‑tender for sand‑mining groups in Shahdol and Katni was unlawful.

Both companies had surrendered earlier sand‑mining contracts and later participated in the September 2025 e‑tender, where they were declared the highest bidders. The Board cancelled the auction, alleging that their fresh bids were lower than the bids they had made before surrendering their contracts.

The Court examined the Madhya Pradesh Sand (Mining, Transportation, Storage and Trading) Rules, 2019, particularly Rule 16, and found that the Rules did not prohibit surrendered contractors from re‑tendering. It also held that the Board could not use the earlier surrendered bids as a benchmark for assessing revenue loss, and that the Board’s discretion was not supported by material justification. The amendment dated 30 January 2026 could not be applied retrospectively.

Consequently, the Court restored the 18 September 2025 tender, directed the corporation to complete allotment to the appellants based on their final bids, and ordered that any subsequent tender for the same sand‑mining groups be stayed.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: M/S Dhanlaxmi Merchandise Pvt. Ltd vs State Of Madhya Pradesh (2026 INSC 1125).