← News
Civil

Supreme Court: Appeal allowed, 2007 gift deed set aside and suit decreed in favour of appellants

The Supreme Court vacated the 2012 and 2022 judgments and decreed the partition suit in favour of the appellants, holding the 2007 gift deed void.

The Supreme Court, comprising Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva, delivered its judgment on 14 October 2026 in the case of B. Anasuyamma (Deceased) versus B. Madhusudan Reddy (Deceased). The Court allowed the appeal, set aside the trial‑court judgment of 2012 and the High Court judgment of 2022, and decreed the suit O.S. No. 250 of 2007 in favour of the appellants, awarding no costs.

The dispute originated from a 1959 family settlement that allocated land among the parties. In 1986 a compromise was reached, which the High Court approved in 1990, granting certain properties to Madhusudan Reddy. Despite this, Madhusudan executed a gift deed in 2007 transferring lands he did not own. The appellants challenged the deed in the 2007 suit, but the trial court dismissed the case in 2012, a decision the High Court affirmed in 2022.

The principal issue was whether the 1986 compromise barred any claim to set aside the 2007 gift deed. The Supreme Court held that the 1959 settlement and the 1986 compromise, which Madhusudan had accepted and the High Court had endorsed, extinguished his right to the gifted lands, rendering the deed void. Consequently, the earlier dismissals were erroneous, the appeal was allowed, and the suit was decreed in favour of the appellants without costs.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: B. Anasuyamma (Died) Per Lrs vs B. Madhusudhan Reddy (Died) As Per Lrs (2026 INSC 1126).