← News
Civil

Supreme Court: Administrator lacked authority to write down Yes Bank AT‑1 bonds, High Court order upheld

Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and affirmed that the RBI‑appointed Administrator could not lawfully write down Yes Bank’s AT‑1 bonds without explicit scheme provision or RBI direction.

The Supreme Court dismissed the appeals filed by Yes Bank Limited and Axis Trustee Services Limited, upholding the Bombay High Court’s decision that the RBI‑appointed Administrator’s write‑down of the bank’s Additional Tier‑1 (AT‑1) bonds was unlawful. The apex court held that the Administrator could not, under section 36ACA of the Banking Regulation Act, reduce the principal of the bonds in the absence of an explicit provision in the final Reconstruction Scheme and without a specific RBI direction.

Yes Bank had issued Basel‑III compliant AT‑1 bonds in 2016‑17 and appointed Axis Trustee as the bond trustee. Following the March 2020 moratorium, the RBI installed an Administrator who, relying on the Master Circular, wrote down the bonds’ principal. The bank challenged the action, arguing that the Administrator’s powers under section 36ACA were limited to statutory functions and could not replace the RBI’s regulatory authority. The court examined whether the Reconstruction Scheme expressly authorised a write‑down and whether the Master Circular permitted such action without a fresh RBI directive.

The Supreme Court concluded that the Administrator lacked authority to effect the write‑down, deeming the action ultra vires. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed, the Bombay High Court’s judgment striking down the write‑down was affirmed, and the interim orders previously granting the write‑down were vacated. Coupon payments on the AT‑1 bonds were ordered to continue in accordance with the Information Memorandum, preserving the bondholders’ rights pending any further restructuring.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Yes Bank Limited vs Axis Trustee Services Limited (2026 INSC 1132).