← News
Civil

Supreme Court: Administration can cancel e‑auction bid before allotment

The Supreme Court held that the Chandigarh Administration was lawfully empowered to cancel the e‑auction contract for Site 4 before issuing an allotment letter and ordered a fresh auction.

The Supreme Court, comprising Justices Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Alok Aradhe, allowed the appeals filed by Satinder Pal Singh and Bedi Hospital and set aside the High Court’s order. The Court directed the Chandigarh Administration to conduct a fresh e‑auction for Site 4 within three months, without awarding costs to either party.

The dispute arose from an e‑auction of nursing‑home sites conducted by the Chandigarh Administration, where M/s Bedi Hospital emerged as the highest bidder for Site 4, paid the full consideration, and subsequently had its bid contract cancelled by the Administration. The Administration justified the cancellation on the ground that the price did not reflect market trends and refunded the amount. The High Court had set aside the cancellation, prompting a fresh auction in which the appellant secured the site at a higher price. The central question was whether the Administration’s cancellation, under the Chandigarh Estate Rules, 2007 and the auction terms, was lawful.

The Supreme Court observed that the agreement to sell becomes enforceable only upon execution of a conveyance deed, and that Rule 5(vi) of the Estate Rules expressly permits the Estate Officer to reject or withdraw a bid without assigning a reason. The Court held that the cancellation was exercised within statutory authority, aimed at obtaining a better price, and was accompanied by a full refund and an opportunity to re‑bid, thereby not constituting arbitrariness or a breach of natural justice. Consequently, the appeals were allowed, the High Court’s order was set aside, and a fresh e‑auction was ordered.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Satinder Pal Singh vs Bedi Hospital (2026 INSC 1142).