← News
Labour & Service

Rajasthan High Court: Seniority list of Assistant Engineers quashed, promotees placed above direct recruits

The court held that promotee petitioners are senior to private respondents appointed under the 1/3 direct‑recruitment quota and ordered a fresh seniority list.

The Rajasthan High Court dismissed the seniority list dated 12‑April‑2016 in the case of Sagra Ram Godara and others versus RRVP NL Jaipur and others. The petitioners, who had been promoted to Assistant Engineer in September 2004, were placed below private respondents appointed in October 2004 under a limited direct‑recruitment quota. The court directed that a new seniority list be issued placing the petitioners above the private respondents, with the attendant benefits.

The petitioners contended that, under the 1969 Engineers Service Regulations, a promotee appointed in the same year as a direct recruit should enjoy seniority over the recruit. The private respondents argued that they were to be treated as direct recruits and therefore senior to the promotees. The dispute centered on the interpretation of Regulation 27(ii) of the 1969 Regulations and a 2003 notification concerning the 1/3‑direct‑recruitment quota.

The court examined the quota provision and held that the private respondents were indeed appointed under the 1/3 direct‑recruitment quota, making them direct recruits. Applying Regulation 27(ii), the court concluded that where appointments occur in the same year, a promotee outranks a direct recruit. The court rejected the respondents’ claim of delay and laches, noting that no third‑party promotions had taken place that would prejudice the petitioners.

Consequently, the seniority list dated 12‑April‑2016 was set aside. The respondents were ordered to prepare a fresh seniority list reflecting the petitioners’ seniority over the private respondents, thereby granting the petitioners the benefits arising from their senior position.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Sagra Ram Godara And Ors vs Rrvpnl Jaipur And Ors (2026:RJ-JD:54500).