← News
Civil

Rajasthan High Court: Dismisses writ, upholds trial court's inspection power

The Rajasthan High Court dismissed the writ petition, confirming the trial court's authority to inspect the disputed shop under Order XVIII Rule 18 CPC despite an interim stay in a related proceeding.

The Rajasthan High Court, hearing Mukesh Kumar v. Smt. Shanta Devi, dismissed the writ petition filed by the petitioners and affirmed the trial court’s order to inspect the shop premises. The bench held that the trial court had correctly exercised its statutory power under Order XVIII Rule 18 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and that the interim stay granted in a related writ proceeding did not bar the inspection.

Petitioner‑defendants Mukesh Kumar and Mahaveer Kumar contested Shanta Devi’s suit for possession of a shop, alleging that the property identified by the plaintiff bore a different Khasra number and that the sale deed relied upon was disputed. The trial court, seeking to resolve the factual controversy, appointed a Court Naazir to inspect the premises under Order XVIII Rule 18 read with Section 151 CPC. The petitioners argued that the inspection exceeded the court’s jurisdiction and that an interim stay in a parallel writ should prevent it.

The High Court observed that Order XVIII Rule 18 expressly authorises a court to order an on‑site inspection at any stage of a suit to ascertain the true nature of the property in dispute, and that such inspection is not a tool for one party to gather evidence surreptitiously. Since the parties were in genuine disagreement over the shop’s identity, the inspection was necessary to resolve the issue. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed and any pending applications were ordered disposed.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Mukesh Kumar vs Smt. Shanta Devi (2026:RJ-JD:52925).