Rajasthan High Court: Application to summon ITRs dismissed
The Rajasthan High Court upheld the trial court’s dismissal of a petition to summon the complainant’s income tax returns in a Section 138 cheque‑dishonor case.
The Rajasthan High Court, hearing Vinod Kumar versus State of Rajasthan, dismissed the petitioner’s application under Section 528 of the Criminal Procedure Code seeking the complainant’s income‑tax returns and books of accounts. The court affirmed the trial court’s order that had rejected the petition, thereby leaving the proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act to continue without the requested documents.
The petitioner, Vinod Kumar, had been charged for dishonouring a cheque issued for a loan of Rs 5,00,000. He argued that the complainant’s tax returns and account books were necessary to challenge the legitimacy of the debt. However, during cross‑examination, the complainant admitted that the loan amount was not reflected in his accounts, making the sought documents redundant for the defence.
The court held that the non‑reflection of the loan in the complainant’s accounts did not constitute a violation of the Income‑Tax Act that would automatically invalidate the debt under Section 138. Consequently, the dismissal of the application did not prejudice the petitioner’s right to defence, and the miscellaneous petition under Section 528 was dismissed, leaving the trial court’s order intact.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: Vinod Kumar vs State Of Rajasthan (2026:RJ-JD:56086).