← News
Civil

Punjab and Haryana HC: Widow awarded compensation in railway accident case

The Punjab and Haryana High Court set aside the Railway Claims Tribunal’s order and awarded compensation to the widow and sons of a deceased railway passenger.

The Punjab and Haryana High Court, sitting as a single judge, allowed the appeal filed by the widow and three sons of the deceased, Ashok Kumar, and directed payment of compensation under the Railways Act, 1989. The bench set aside the order of the Railway Claims Tribunal, which had dismissed the claim on the ground that the deceased was not a passenger and that the incident did not qualify as an untoward event. The court therefore awarded the appellants the relief sought.

Ashok Kumar was alleged to have fallen from a moving train on 14 March 2015, resulting in his death. The Railway Claims Tribunal rejected the claim, doubting his status as a bona‑fide passenger and questioning whether his death fell within Section 123(c)(2) of the Railways Act as an untoward incident. The appellants contended that he possessed a verified ticket, that police and inquest reports corroborated his presence on the train, and that his injuries were consistent with a fall from a running carriage.

The High Court examined the ticket, police and inquest reports, and medical evidence, finding them reliable and sufficient to establish that the deceased was a bona‑fide passenger and that his fall constituted an untoward incident under the statute. Applying a liberal construction of Sections 123 and 124‑A, the court held that the widow and three sons were the only dependants eligible for relief. Accordingly, it ordered payment of Rs 4 lakh with 9 % simple interest from filing, or Rs 8 lakh whichever is higher, within three months, with additional interest for delay as prescribed.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: URMILA DEVI AND ORS vs UNION OF INDIA (2026:PHHC:199204).