← News
Criminal

Punjab and Haryana HC: Discharges accused for lack of prima facie material in murder and conspiracy case

The court set aside the charge‑framing order and discharged the accused, finding no admissible suspicion under Sections 302 and 120‑B IPC.

The Punjab and Haryana High Court, presiding Justice Manisha Batra, discharged Alok Kumar Shah after quashing the charge‑framing order under Sections 302 and 120‑B of the Indian Penal Code. The trial court had earlier framed charges based on a supplementary statement of the complainant.

The FIR and investigation had identified two other accomplices, while the petitioner was mentioned only in a supplementary statement that relied on hearsay and lacked any eyewitness identification. The approver’s statement also excluded the petitioner, and no direct evidence linked him to the alleged offence.

The court examined whether the material before the Additional Sessions Judge satisfied the requirement of a strong, admissible suspicion under Section 227 of the Criminal Procedure Code. Citing precedents, it held that hearsay statements cannot be converted into evidence and that the absence of direct identification meant the test for framing a charge was not met.

Consequently, the charge‑framing order was set aside, the charges were quashed, and the petitioner was discharged, as the prosecution failed to establish a prima facie case against him.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: ALOK KUMAR SHAH vs STATE OF PUNJAB & ANR (2026:PHHC:200434).