Punjab and Haryana HC: Amendment of pleadings denied due to material alteration and delay
The court upheld the trial court’s refusal to allow a belated amendment that materially changed the suit’s nature and introduced a new cause of action.
The Punjab and Haryana High Court, presided over by Justice Virinder Aggarwal, dismissed the revision petition filed by the petitioner seeking to amend his 2018 suit for permanent injunction. The amendment sought to add a mandatory injunction for restoration of possession, alleging forcible dispossession and demolition of the property during the suit’s pendency.
The petitioner claimed ownership of ancestral property and argued that the amendment was necessary to reflect the changed circumstances. The trial court had refused the amendment, holding that it sought to replace the original description of a ground‑floor dilapidated room with a three‑storeyed building and introduced a fresh claim without specifying the date of dispossession.
The High Court examined whether the amendment, filed after a long delay, materially altered the pleadings or introduced a new cause of action, which would be prohibited under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC. It emphasized that amendments must be bona‑fide, cannot be used to mask delay or prejudice, and may not substantially change the nature of the suit at a highly belated stage.
Finding that the amendment indeed sought to replace the original description and raised a new claim, the Court upheld the trial court’s order denying the amendment. Consequently, the revision petition was dismissed as devoid of merit, and the original order stood.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: SURJIT SINGH vs SANDEEP ARORA AND OTHERS (2026:PHHC:196269).