← News
Civil

Madras HC: Selection committee void for lack of subject expert, appointments set aside

The court held the expert committee was improperly constituted and annulled the appointments of two assistant professors.

The Madras High Court, presided over by Justice C. Kumarappan, allowed the petition of Dr. Binu Kumar and declared the appointments of two candidates to the OBC‑reserved Assistant Professor post in Performing Arts void. The court directed that a fresh de novo interview be conducted within four weeks by a properly constituted expert panel.

Dr. Binu Kumar had applied for the post advertised on 29‑10‑2019 and, after an interview on 08‑06‑2023, the university’s Vice‑Chancellor, Executive Committee and Selection Committee appointed two respondents despite his claim of exclusive qualification. The petitioner challenged the validity of the selection committee, arguing that it did not include an expert in Drama and Theatre Arts as required by the Pondicherry University Ordinance.

The court examined Ordinance 19, Clause 7 of the Pondicherry University Act, which mandates the inclusion of a subject‑expert in the selection committee. Relying on the ratio in N. Mani (2025), the court held that a committee lacking the required expert is defective and its decisions are void. It noted that the specialization mentioned in the notification was merely desirable, not essential, and the appointed candidates possessed the necessary qualifications, but the statutory requirement was not satisfied.

Consequently, the court set aside the appointments of the two respondents and ordered a fresh interview with a duly constituted expert panel. The respondents were directed to appoint the candidates selected through this process, and no costs were awarded.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: DR. L. BINU KUMAR vs THE VICE CHANCELLOR (2026/MHC/4555).