Madras HC: Remand does not erase earlier evidence or change witness rank
The Madras High Court held that evidence recorded before a remand under Order XLI Rule 23A remains on record and the rank of previously examined witnesses must be retained.
The Madras High Court, presided over by Justice N. Anand Venkatesh, set aside the trial court’s order dated 29‑08‑2023 and directed the trial court to record additional evidence without altering the rank of existing witnesses. The petitioners had sought correction of the trial court’s treatment of a witness previously examined as P.W.2 as P.W.1 and the re‑marking of documents after the appellate court remanded the case for fresh disposal.
The petition arose from a civil suit where the trial court, after remand, had re‑ordered the witness list and required re‑numbering of documents. The central issue was whether a remand under Order XLI Rule 23A of the CPC extinguishes evidence already recorded and whether the rank of witnesses examined before remand must be changed.
The Court examined the language of Order XLI Rule 23A, the Madras Amendment, Law Commission recommendations and earlier decisions such as Amal Mal Sindhi v. Ram Prakash, Sampa Acharyya v. Malay Acharyya and J. Balaji Singh v. Diwakar Cole. It concluded that a remand does not constitute a de novo trial; earlier evidence remains admissible as additional evidence unless a specific exception is shown, and only newly examined witnesses receive new ranks.
Accordingly, the impugned order was set aside. The trial court was instructed to record only additional evidence, retain the existing witness ranks, assign new serial numbers only to newly marked documents, and dispose of the suit within four months. No costs were awarded.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: ANDALAMMAL vs DJEALATCHOUMY (2026/MHC/4565).