Madras HC: Regularisation upheld, unaided school not bound to Seventh Pay salary
The court upheld the 2009 regularisation of the vocational teacher and quashed the order requiring the minority school to pay Seventh Pay salaries.
The Madras High Court, presided over by Justice C. Kumarappan, dismissed a mandamus petition filed by vocational instructor C.R. Kasturi and allowed a certiorari petition, setting aside an order that had directed an unaided minority school to pay her salary under the Seventh Pay Commission.
Kasturi had been appointed as a vocational instructor in May 1997 and was regularised by the Government in April 2009 through G.O.(2D).No.14, with the condition of receiving only a contributory pension. The school, being an unaided minority institution, later sought to align her salary and benefits with those of government teachers under the Seventh Pay Commission.
The court examined whether the 2009 regularisation could be retrospectively altered and whether the school was obligated to match government pay scales. It observed that the regularisation order was unchallenged and that earlier case law dealt only with fresh regularisation, not modification of an existing order. The court also relied on the Full Bench decision in T. Sorubarani, which held that compelling unaided minority schools to follow government pay structures infringes Article 30(1) of the Constitution.
Consequently, the mandamus petition was dismissed, the certiorari petition was allowed, and the order directing the school to pay salary under the Seventh Pay Commission was quashed. No costs were awarded to either party.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: C.R.KASTURI vs THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU (2026/MHC/4561).