← News
Civil

Madras HC: Arbitrator's award to refund EMD upheld, interest reduced to 9%

The Madras High Court affirmed the arbitrator’s refund award of Rs 45,67,330 and lowered post‑award interest from 12% to 9% per annum.

The Madras High Court, presided by Justice D. Bharatha Chakravarthy, upheld the arbitrator’s award directing the State Trading Corporation of India Limited to refund Rs 45,67,330 earned as earnest money deposit (EMD) to Rajni Exports and Imports, while reducing the post‑award interest rate to 9% per annum.

The State Trading Corporation had issued an e‑tender for urad dal, which Rajni Exports and Imports won. The respondent paid part of the price, obtained extensions, and eventually paid the balance along with carrying costs. The petitioner later sought to forfeit the EMD, prompting arbitration.

The central issue was whether the arbitrator was justified in setting aside the petitioner’s claim for forfeiture and whether the award could be interfered with under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The court found that the parties’ subsequent conduct effectively modified the time‑for‑performance clause, the respondent had fulfilled its obligations, and the forfeiture clause could not be enforced.

The court held that the arbitrator’s interpretation of the contract fell within his jurisdiction, giving no ground to set aside the award. The only error identified was the interest rate, which the court corrected to 9% per annum in line with established principles, and no costs were awarded.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: The State Trading Corporation of India Limited vs Rajni Exports and Imports, (2026/MHC/4606).