Madras HC: Ancestral land partition decree modified, after‑born children recognized as coparceners
The Madras High Court held the land to be ancestral, recognized daughters as coparceners, and ruled that 2005‑06 settlement deeds do not bind them, altering the decree.
The Madras High Court, presided over by Justice N. Sathish Kumar, modified the preliminary decree in MAHAVEER CHAND RANKA vs TMT. A. Kanagalakshmi, allocating specific square‑foot shares of the remaining 4 grounds 7 sq ft of land among the heirs. The court also partly allowed OSA‑304 and OSA‑370, disposed OSA‑390, and closed all connected petitions without costs.
The suit concerned a J‑schedule parcel that formed part of a 1956 partition deed of V. G. Vellaya Nadar’s estate. Two daughters (plaintiffs) and several defendants, including sons, daughters and later purchasers, claimed differing shares. Settlement deeds executed in 2005‑2006 by the father and mother were also contested.
The principal issue was whether the J‑schedule land constituted ancestral property and whether after‑born children, including daughters, became coparceners entitled to a share under the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005. The court examined the effect of the statutory cut‑off date of 20 December 2004 on settlement deeds affecting ancestral property.
Applying principles from earlier decisions and the Hindu Succession Act, the court held that the land was ancestral and that after‑born children are coparceners with a right to inherit the father’s share. Consequently, the 2005‑06 settlement deeds could not bind them, and the shares were recalculated under Sections 8 and 15 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: MAHAVEER CHAND RANKA vs TMT.A.KANAGALAKSHMI (2026/MHC/4559).