Karnataka High Court: State cannot appoint chief executive for non‑assisted co‑operative
The court held that the State could not use Section 29‑G to take over management of a co‑operative society that did not qualify as an assisted society.
The Karnataka High Court, comprising Judges M. Nagaprasanna and Hema Kulkaarni, dismissed the writ appeal filed by the State of Karnataka and affirmed the voidness of its communication dated 18‑01‑2011 directing the Assistant Director of Horticulture to assume day‑to‑day management of the co‑operative society U.K. Jilla Totada Belagarara. The court ruled that the State could not appoint a chief executive under Section 29‑G of the Karnataka Co‑operative Societies Act, 1959.
The dispute arose when the State issued a directive for administrative takeover of the society, asserting that it was an ‘assisted society’ within the meaning of the Act. The society contested the directive, arguing that it had never received any share capital, loan, grant or guarantee from the State, which are the statutory criteria for being classified as an assisted society under Section 2(a‑1‑1). The legal question was whether the State could invoke Section 29‑G in the absence of such assistance.
The court interpreted Section 2(a‑1‑1) strictly, finding that the society had not received any of the specified forms of assistance and therefore did not meet the definition of an assisted society. Consequently, Section 29‑G could not be applied, as it authorises State appointment only for assisted societies or upon a request by the society itself. The court also held that a later amendment to the Act could not retrospectively validate the 2011 communication. The impugned directive was declared void and the writ appeal dismissed.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: The State Of Karnataka VS U K Jilla Totada Belagarara (2026:KHC-D:18684).