Karnataka HC: Single Bench of State Human Rights Commission Lacked Jurisdiction in Custodial Torture Complaint
The court quashed two orders of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission and remitted the case for fresh hearing by a Division Bench.
The Karnataka High Court, presided over by Justice T.P. Vivekananda, set aside two orders of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission that had recommended disciplinary action against petitioner Sri Laxman K. Pawar based on a complaint of illegal detention and custodial torture. The orders, dated 29 November 2022 and 26 February 2024, were made by a Single Bench of the Commission.
The petitioner challenged the jurisdiction of the Single Bench, arguing that under sub‑regulation (4) of Regulation 11 of the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 2007, complaints of illegal detention and custodial torture must be heard by a Division Bench unless the Chairperson specifically directs otherwise. The Commission had not issued such a direction.
The High Court examined the language of the regulation, noting that the term “normally” coupled with “shall” indicated a mandatory requirement for a Division Bench hearing in such matters. It further held that the 2020 amendment to the regulations did not repeal the 2007 provision governing bench composition. Consequently, the Single Bench was found to have acted without jurisdiction.
The court quashed the two Commission orders and remitted the matter to the Karnataka State Human Rights Commission for fresh adjudication by a Division Bench, leaving all parties’ contentions open for consideration.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: SRI LAXMAN K PAWAR VS THE KARNATAKA STATE HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION (2026:KHC:61510).