← News
Constitutional

Gauhati High Court: Tender Committee Cannot Override Mandatory Qualification Criteria

The court set aside the award to M/S Vidur, holding that mandatory turnover and experience requirements cannot be relaxed under MSME policies.

The Gauhati High Court, presided over by Justice Arun Dev Choudhury, dismissed the award of the Material Recovery Facility and Waste‑to‑Compost plant contract to M/S Vidur, ruling that the Tender Evaluation Committee could not deem the bidder technically qualified by ignoring mandatory criteria.

The tender required bidders to have completed two similar projects in Assam and to demonstrate an average annual turnover of at least Rs 7.5 crore. M/S Vidur submitted a lower turnover figure and only one similar work, yet was declared technically qualified and awarded the L1 position, prompting M/S Call and Fix to challenge the decision.

The issue was whether the Assam Procurement Preference Policy 2021 and the 2016 Ministry of MSME circular could lawfully relax those mandatory financial and experience requirements. The court held that the Assam Public Procurement Act 2017 and the 2020 Rules mandate uniform application of qualification criteria and prohibit any waiver, and that the MSME policy and central circular do not create a blanket exemption for state procurements.

Consequently, the court set aside the committee’s decision and the L1 award to Vidur, directing the procuring authority either to re‑evaluate the bids strictly according to the original criteria or to lawfully cancel the tender and re‑tender the procurement.

Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: M/S CALL AND FIX (CAF), vs STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS (2026:GAU-AS:16325).