Gauhati High Court: Petitioner barred from challenging penalty after accepting instalment payment
The court dismissed the writ petition, holding the LPG distributor estopped from contesting the penalty after he paid it in instalments.
The Gauhati High Court, presided over by Justice Devashis Baruah, dismissed a writ petition filed by a LPG distributor who had been penalised Rs 10,77,989 for missing cylinders and regulators. The petitioner had obtained permission to pay the penalty in twelve instalments, complied with the schedule, and then sought to set aside the penalty on procedural grounds. The court held that having accepted the benefit of the order by completing the instalment payments, the petitioner could not later challenge its validity.
The petitioner argued that his reply to the show‑cause notice had been ignored and that Clause 2.1 of the relevant guidelines was not mentioned, contending these procedural lapses rendered the penalty unlawful. The court examined whether a party who pays a penal order, even under protest, retains the right to question the order’s procedural correctness thereafter. It referred to the Supreme Court’s doctrine of ‘approbate and reprobate’ and the principle of election, which prevent a party from accepting and rejecting the same order.
Applying the doctrine, the court concluded that the petitioner’s actions—requesting instalment payment, signing a declaration of liability, and making all payments—constituted acceptance of the order. Consequently, any subsequent invocation of procedural defects was barred. The writ petition was dismissed without costs, affirming that once a party elects to benefit from an order, it is estopped from contesting that order on procedural grounds.
Read the judgment and its head note on DLJ: JISHU SUKLABAIDYA vs THE UNION OF INDIA AND 16 ORS. (2026:GAU-AS:16395).